I have been interested in this game ever since I've seen this thread, but have never been able to find it at BFG so I finally decided it wasn't a BFG game. Today I decided to give it one more try and since quite a bit of time has passed I figured it would be an older game and maybe that's why I was having no luck at finding it. (My brain finally kicked in, i guess.) Anyway, today I looked for the game by genre, looked at the list for all Hidden Object games and I had to scroll quite a long way down, but finally, there it was, Dreamscapes: The Sandman. I immediately clicked on it and while reading about the girl and her dreams and losing the dreamcatcher, I had the feeling that I had played a game just like this. Sure enough, back in April, 2013. Good game, too!